Bonhoeffer's Legacy

(The Lily Phillips story, the persecution of a small town mayor, & other stories)

Hello all,

A few articles for you today:

The Bridgehead: “The tragic Lily Phillips story is another reason we should ban porn.”

Reformed Perspective: “The case against blood sports.”

Interview: “Why Atheism Failed with Spencer Klavan.”

Bonhoeffer’s Christian Legacy

First published at The European Conservative

Dietrich Bonhoeffer is, deservedly, one of the most well-known resistance figures of the Second World War. One of the few Germans to speak out against Hitler and the Nazis at the height of their power, he preached against the persecution of the Jews and condemned the Nazi euthanasia program. He became one of the founders of the Confessing Church, a faction of German Protestants committed to resisting Hitler’s takeover and the consolidation of the German Evangelical Church that emerged in the 1930s.

Bonhoeffer was arrested in April 1943 and, after being incarcerated at Tegel Prison for over a year, he was sent to Flossenbürg concentration camp. Although the historical record is inconclusive about his involvement, Bonhoeffer was accused of being part of the 20 July 1944 plot to assassinate Hitler. He was hanged on 9 April 1945, as the Third Reich collapsed. Both his imprisonment and execution are portrayed in the final scenes of Bonhoeffer, the new biopic by Angel Studios.

Predictably, Bonhoeffer’s portrayal in the film has triggered a vigorous historical debate. The docudrama is compelling, although extensive creative liberties were taken with regard to his involvement in the July 20 plot (the subtitle refers to him incorrectly as an “assassin”), and the nuances of Bonhoeffer’s theological views—and the tensions between his pacifism and his resistance activities—are left entirely unexplored. Some reviews, such as Joel Looper’s in First Things, have been scorching, and fair enough: the “based on a true story” disclaimer was definitely warranted.

The film has given Bonhoeffer scholars cause once again to accuse conservatives of ‘hijacking’ Bonhoeffer; many insist that, in his bestselling biography, Eric Metaxas portrayed Bonhoeffer as an American evangelical rather than the complex German theologian that he was. And indeed, Bonhoeffer’s theological views were, in many instances, far from orthodox. But it must be pointed out that it isn’t just conservatives who wish to claim Bonhoeffer. I suspect Bonhoeffer would be appalled to see how progressives are using his name, as well.

Take Angela Denker’s review for Slate.com, titled “I’m Pretty Sure Dietrich Bonhoeffer Would Have Hated Bonhoeffer.” Denker bemoans the pain of watching “the right slowly claim one of your lifelong heroes” while vigorously straw-manning American evangelicals. Denker—a female pastor—claims that a Bonhoeffer relative told her that the famous pastor would be “turning in his grave” to see his words being used to, for example, oppose “women’s reproductive rights.” But Bonhoeffer rather unambiguously referred to abortion as “murder”:

Destruction of the embryo in the mother’s womb is a violation of the right to live which God has bestowed upon this nascent life. To raise the question whether we are here concerned already with a human being or not is merely to confuse the issue. The simple fact is that God certainly intended to create a human being and that this nascent human being has been deliberately deprived of his life. And this is nothing but murder.

A great many different motives may lead to an action of this kind; indeed in cases where it is an act of despair, performed in circumstances of extreme human or economic destitution and misery, the guilt may often lie rather with the community than with the individual. Precisely in this connection money may conceal many a wanton deed, while the poor man’s more reluctant lapse may far more easily be disclosed. All these considerations must no doubt have a quite decisive influence on our personal and pastoral attitude towards the person concerned, but they cannot in any way alter the fact of murder.

Who, exactly, is recruiting who? Pro-lifers do not need to ‘recruit’ Bonhoeffer—he identified abortion as murder before we were born and was also a rigorous opponent of all forms of euthanasia. Bonhoeffer’s views certainly defy the simplistic political categorizations to which we are accustomed, but it is absolutely fair to point out that he would be “turning in his grave” to see his name used to defend a procedure he referred to as “murder,” considering that he was willing to risk death and face execution in opposition to a regime built on murder.

Several reviewers have accused Angel Studios of producing some sort of MAGA nationalist Bonhoeffer, but this seems to be projection. Many, including Denker, condemn Christians who oppose LGBT ideology (which the film doesn’t mention), with the strong implication that Bonhoeffer, if alive today, would be heavily into all that. None seem to see the irony in asserting that Bonhoeffer would be a backer of the sexual revolution and the new state ideology. It is the rainbow flag that many churches hoist now, and even President-Elect Trump obediently hosted a victory party to celebrate the LGBT movement’s accomplishments at Mar-A-Lago.

It is true that some conservatives would like to baptize Bonhoeffer as one of them; it is also true that progressives, who are fond of comparing their ideological opponents to Nazis, would like to portray Bonhoeffer as a trans-identifying Episcopalian bishop who smuggles abortion pills into red states. Indeed, just as the Scholl siblings of the White Rose resistance are consistently portrayed as defenders of ‘democracy’ and ‘liberalism’ rather than the devout Christian dissidents they actually were, Bonhoeffer has been recast as the sort of hero whom progressives can get behind.

But it is the fierce faith of these resistance figures that should compel us and challenge us. Twenty-one-year-old Sophie Scholl uttered her parting words as she crossed the prison courtyard to the guillotine on February 22, 1943: “Such a fine, sunny day, and I have to go. But how many must die on the battlefields, how many promising young men … What does my death matter, if through us, thousands of people are awakened and stirred to action?” And then, just before the blade fell: “God, you are my refuge into eternity.”

Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s last words as he faced the noose at the age of 39 were: “This is the end—for me, the beginning of life.”

***

LGBT activists continue to target 77-year-old small town mayor Harold McQuaker—this time, they garnished his bank account and took thousands of dollars against his will simply because he would not issue a Pride proclamation. Watch:

As always, follow the podcast wherever you get your content, if interested! Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Rumble, or YouTube.

I also have a number of short culture updates at The Bridgehead, and if you’re interested in a copy of my new book How We Got Here: A Guide to Our Anti-Christian Culture, you can buy it at Amazon.com, Amazon.ca, or at The Bridgehead.